Front Page

Welcome to the blog of Paul Burkhart. Take a look around, read some posts, click some links, and please feel free to engage in the discussions. Be sure to check out the links above for more information.

Recent Posts

On #Ferguson: Why Police & Military Should Be Different [QUOTE]

ferguson-military-policeEver since the police in Ferguson, Missouri brought out their military gear in response to peaceful protests after the fatal shooting of an unarmed black teenager, there has been a new conversation about the increasingly blurred lines between the police and the military. I have very good friends that cannot seem to understand why there needs to be any distinction. Force is force, right? Well, in my reading recently, I came across this relevant quote I thought I’d share:

The distinction made here between police and war is not simply a matter of the degree to which the appeal to force, goes, the number of persons killed or killing. It is a structural and profound difference in the sociological meaning of the appeal to force.
In the police function, the violence or threat thereof is applied only to the offending party. The use of violence by the agent of the police is subject to review by higher authorities. The police officer applies power within the limits of a state whose legislation even the criminal knows to be applicable to him. In any orderly police system there are serious safeguards to keep the violence of the police from being applied in a wholesale way against the innocent. The police power generally is great enough to overwhelm that of the individual offender so that any resistance on the offender’s part is pointless.

In all of these respects, war is structurally different. The doctrine of the “just war” is an effort to extend into the realm of war the logic of the limited violence of police authority–but not a very successful one. There is some logic to the “just war” pattern of thought but very little realism.

–John Howard Yoder, The Politics of Jesus

In short, you shouldn’t appeal to policing tactics to justify military force, and you shouldn’t use military tactics in policing.

[photo credit: Whitney Curtis for the New York Times]

  1. The Refuge of the Embattled Soul Leave a reply
  2. Cultivating Your Soul to Lead Leave a reply
  3. My first Sunday Morning Sermon. I’d like to share it with you. 4 Replies
  4. Hey Church Planters! A Quick Question for you. 3 Replies
  5. A Sermon I Got to Preach on Isaiah 61 [VIDEO] 2 Replies
  6. Congrats to the Women of the Church of England! Leave a reply
  7. Faith & Grace Alone: Job & the New Perspective on Paul| Job 9 1 Reply
  8. #Marginalia Weekly Round-Up #6 [Catch-Up] Leave a reply
  9. Is There No Rest for God’s Weary Ministers? | Mark 6 Leave a reply
  10. Job’s Friends are Right! Job’s Friends are Wrong.| Job 8.5-7,20-22 1 Reply
  11. Should Protestantism Still Be a Thing? 3 Replies
  12. How Preaching Saved Me from Evangelicalism’s Bible 5 Replies
  13. Paul: The Second Coming of Jonah? 2 Replies
  14. Logos Bible Software & Evangelical Insecurity 10 Replies